12 Popular Movies Pushed on Reddit That Were Disappointing When We Finally Watched Them

If you’ve ever gone online, then you’ve probably seen countless “best movie ever” lists. Well, a popular place people go for film recommendations is Reddit – a few titles come up most often. They’re not for everyone, though; here are some popular movies pushed on Reddit that were disappointing when folks finally saw them.

It’s possible that some of these films are on your “to-watch list.” Maybe take a pause and make sure each one is for you before giving in to the hype.

What We Do in the Shadows

What We Do in the Shadows Movie.
Image Credit: Unison Films.

I often see both the movie and TV series recommended online but not everyone enjoyed this film when they finally checked it out.

“The whole movie feels like an overstretched SNL skit.” the commentator said. Others agreed, and some added that comedy (especially satire or comedy horror) is really hard to recommend because it’s not for everyone.


JASON MOMOA as Aquaman in Warner Bros. Pictures’ action adventure “Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom,” a Warner Bros. Pictures release.
Image Credit: Courtesy Warner Bros Pictures and DC Comics.

I was surprised to see this one since I thought that most people had a negative opinion of this Jason Momoa film – at least that’s how it was in my circles.

“I’m very confused by how many people here seem to have genuinely enjoyed Aquaman.” a Redditor commented. Others added that it’s just very polarizing; either you like it or you don’t.

Black Panther

Bangkok, Thailand - February 17, 2018: Beautiful Standee of A Marvel Superhero Movie Black Panther Display at the theater.
Image Credit: Sarunyu L/Shutterstock.

It was unique and definitely a solid Marvel flick, but is it as good as everyone says? Some people don’t think so.

One comment tried to explain their point of view, saying “I get the social significance. But I thought it was a decent action flick, that’s all.” Others weren’t so nice and said it wasn’t a good movie at all.


Image Credit: CJ Entertainment.

I actually finally watched this one earlier today so it’s fresh in my memory. I thought it totally lived up to the hype, but apparently not everyone felt the same way.

“I’m the only person I’ve ever met that did not enjoy Parasite” one person said, but a lot of people upvoted or replied in agreement. Others didn’t mind the film but felt it was simply overrated.

Everything Everywhere All at Once

Everything Everywhere All at Once.
Image Credit: A24.

Woah woah woah, this movie isn’t just loved by Reddit but by most critics too. So what did people dislike about it, you ask? For some it was just too zany, which made it a lot less enjoyable for folks who wanted something more serious.


Image Credit: Disney Plus.

My favorite response to this suggestion was this comment: “Exactly, if I wanted to watch old ladies struggle living I’d go to my family reunion.”


Anyway, Nomadland is a movie about a woman in her 60s who lost everything in the Great Recession and then took her RV on a cross-country trip. It was good enough to be nominated for an Academy Award but that doesn’t mean this one’s everyone’s cup of tea.

La La Land

La La Land.
Image Credit: Summit Entertainment.

If you don’t like musicals then that’s already a sign you won’t enjoy La La Land. But even some people who do like them still feel this movie is overhyped on the internet.

In concept, La La Land is a throwback film to those big Hollywood musical blockbuster movies. In practice, though, they hired famous actors rather than singers/dancers and it shows.


(L-r) TIMOTHÉE CHALAMET as Paul Atreides and ZENDAYA as Chani in Warner Bros. Pictures and Legendary Pictures’ action adventure “DUNE: PART TWO,”.
Image Credit: Niko Tavernise/Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc.

The consensus on this one is that the majority of people who love and recommend the Dune movies (both old and new ones) are folks who already like the book series. If you weren’t already familiar with the source material the movie, especially the new one, might feel lacking or even boring as a science fiction film.

Lake Mungo

Lake Mungo.
Image Credit: Lions Gate.

This horror film is often recommended when people are looking for something really scary but not everyone gets creeped out by it in the same way its fans do. This is especially true if you’re not a fan of found footage/mockumentary style horror films.

The Super Mario Brothers Movie

The Super Mario Brothers Movie.
Image Credit: Universal Pictures.

I like the song Jack Black sings but after watching a bit of this with my kids I can totally see how some folks found it disappointing. Cute, yes, but for these adults it seemed like a bunch of nostalgia packed together with actors that didn’t feel right for their roles.


Image Credit: Moho Film.

A real controversial take here! It seems like everyone online loves Snowpiercer so if you didn’t care for it take comfort in finally knowing that, unlike the folks on that train, you’re not alone.


Image Credit: Universal Pictures.

The real issue with Oppenheimer hate is that people went into it thinking it was a movie about the Manhattan Project when in reality it was a biopic of Oppenheimer’s life. As such, a significant part of the movie was what happened after the bomb was made – which left some viewers disappointed and even bored with the film.

The Top 12 Funniest Movies of All Time According to the Internet

Image Credit: Cinecorp SAC.

Need a laugh? We rounded up the top 12 funniest movies of all time, at least according to people on the internet. Whether they’re your top picks or something new to watch, these films are guaranteed to make you laugh all the way through.

In fact, I’ll bet you’ll be quoting most of these long after the movie’s over.

The Top 12 Funniest Movies of All Time According to the Internet 

19 Netflix Shows That Are So Addictive, You’ll Binge-Watch Them in One Sitting

Image Credit: Parisa Taghizadeh/Netflix.

Are you tired of scrolling endlessly through Netflix, trying to find something new to watch? Netflix has so many amazing shows, but finding one to watch can be difficult. Check out these 19 awesome shows and get the popcorn ready!

19 Netflix Shows That Are So Addictive, You’ll Binge-Watch Them in One Sitting 

The 25 Absolutely Best Netflix Original Series of All Time

Jonathan Bailey as Anthony Bridgerton in episode 205 of Bridgerton.

Netflix’s rotating lineup of excellent shows aside, their impressive original series and programming collection are not to be missed.

The 25 Absolutely Best Netflix Original Series of All Time 

12 Movies That People See as Masterpieces Even if Critics Down Agree

Image Credit: New Line Cinema.

Do you have a movie that you don’t just love, but consider to be absolute perfection? Well these folks do, and they shared these movies that people see as masterpieces – even though they’re not considered as such by the mainstream.

The big problem with movies is that they’re subjective. So just because critics didn’t call a movie a masterpiece (plenty of good films get overlooked!) doesn’t mean it’s not worthy of the title.

12 Movies That People See as Masterpieces Even if Critics Down Agree 

12 Must Watch TV Series That You Can Stream on Netflix Right Now

Image Credit:
Emmanuel Guimier / NETFLIX.


Sick of booting up Netflix and having no idea what to watch next? Miss that “surprise me” button that they took away for some reason? Well, I’ve got a solution for you! Here’s 12 must-watch TV series that you can stream on Netflix right now.

Because there’s nothing more annoying than a list of series where you have to buy 10 different streaming services to catch them all!

12 Must Watch TV Series That You Can Stream on Netflix Right Now


Leave a Comment